About Us

Treasure Island Desserts offers the finest Frozen Yogurt, Gelato, and Ice Cream available with 40+ tasty toppings to add to one of our frozen delights. If that's not enough to satisfy your sweet tooth we also offer cakes, pastries, & delicacies that are sure to please even the most hardened castaway. Book your next children's event or social gathering at Treasure Island Desserts, recently voted Long Island's Best Frozen Yogurt store for the 2nd year in a row! Watch our News 12 Video for Stone Grissom's Dishin Long Island:

long island best frozen yogurt store

Discover Our Treasures

At Treasure Island Desserts, we are much more than a Long Island Frozen Yogurt Store. If your feeling stranded and dreaming about an ice cold frozen yogurt, ice cream or gelato with your choice of 40 toppings…a refreshing cappuccino with a croissant….heading to Jones Beach…Treasure Island Desserts should be your destination.

Book Your Next Event

Treasure Island has plenty of space for you to hold your next event. If you’re planning in advance or looking for that last minute place to hold a party at a fun place, give us a call. We can accommodate parties of 35+ people and we have plenty of tasty and sweet treats for you to choose from.

long island birthday bar bat mitzvah

Birthday Parties

Treasure Island Desserts is available for your next birthday party, bar mitzvah, or bat mitzvah. We have more than enough room to fit the kids, and we offer them plenty of choices of Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt with 40+ toppings…

long island frozen yogurt store events

Corporate & Social Events

We also hold Corporate & Social events here at Treasure Island. We offer a delicious...


We have space for your next birthday party or social event.

(516) 261-9900

Give us a call or click the button below as our event space is filling fast for Spring 2018


Join the “Castaway Club”

Join the Castaway Club and Signup to receive emails regarding Treasure Island Desserts specials, events and other happenings at Long Island Favorite Frozen Yogurt Destination for 2017 & 2018. Just fill out your email address below and click "Subscribe":

Visitors Love Treasure Island

At Treasure Island Desserts we pride ourselves on making sure this Long Island Frozen Yogurt & Ice Cream Store leaves every customer satisfied. Here are a few remarks left by our customers on Google, Facebook and Yelp:

Excellent place to enjoy desserts anytime of day! With inside and outside seating available for your comfort, highly recommended for all!!

Contact the Island

If you have any further questions about our menu options, dietary information, catering package or event booking feel free to fill out the form below or give us a call at (516) 261-9900.