At Treasure Island Desserts we have a wonderful section of frozen yogurt ice cream and gelato with 40+ toppings to sooth any craving your sweet tooth desires. We now offer breakfast options, along with delicious cakes & pastries that are sure to please any castaway. If you have any questions about our menu please feel free to give us a call or fill out the information form below.

Premium Ice Cream
Chocolate Craze
Very Vanilla

long island frozen dessert store

Non Fat Frozen Yogurt
Roasted Marshmellow
Caribbean Caramel Banana
Strawberry Shortcake
Birthday Cake Bash

long island frozen dessert store

Low Fat Frozen Yogurt
Cookies 'n Cream
Crazy Coconut
Fun Fudge Brownie

Breakfast Menu

Apple Fritters
Assorted Bagels with butter or cream cheese
Cinnamon Buns
Assorted Danishes Donuts Muffins
Nutella Croissants

Coffees, Teas & Espresso Drinks

Imported Italian Coffees
Iced Coffee with/without Milk

Brownies, Cupcakes & Cookies

Brownie (With Ice Cream)
Large Chocolate Chip Cookie (W/ Ice Cream)
Large M&M Cookie (W/ Ice Cream)
Chocolate Lindzer Tart
Raspberry Lindzer Tart

Edible Cookie Dough Batter

Brownie Batter
Chocolate Chip / Oreo
Cookies & Cream | Confetti

Cakes & Pastries

Apple Strudel Slice (With Ice Cream)
Carrot Cake / Crumb Cake
Rainbow Cake
Raspberry Bar

Smoothies & Drinks

Four Berry Blend
Mango Tropics
Pineapple Paradise
Strawberry Banana


Assorted Sprinkles / Birthday Cake Cubes / Blackberry / Blue Raspberry Waffles / Brownie Bites / Butterfingers / Caramel / Cheesecake Cubes / Cherries and Cherry Sauces / Chocolate Chip and Double Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough / Chopped Peanuts / Coconut / Crunchies / Fruity Pebbles / Granola / Gummy Bears and Worms / Hot Fudge / Kiwi, Strawberry and Passion Fruit Boba / Marshmellow / Oreo / Pineapple / Rainbow Cookies / Raspberries / Reese's Cups & Pieces / S'mores / Snickers / Snicker Doodle Cookie / Strawberry / Walnuts / Whipped Cream / Yogurt Chips